The Same Thing In Different
Format
Authors note: This
piece explains and analyzes how a text differs from a film, specifically Hunger
Games and how the text version is better. I wrote this piece to score high on
text analysis.
Haven’t we all seen things we wish we could see in a different
way? We as humans like to see things in a variety of ways simply to see if they
live up the hype. Take the book Hunger
Games by Suzanne Collins for example. Everybody had read the book and once
they announced a movie was coming out, fans were going berserk! Many fans were disappointed
as they expected more from the movie, and I am going to prove how a book
version is better than film and how it differs.
First of all, When we read a text, our mind has no barriers
and we can think the unthinkable about how a certain character or scene looks. Imagining
and creating the scenes and characters is all part of the fun that comes with
reading. When we watch a film, we are given things a certain way and have no
control over how things look. Once we see a character in a film, when we go
back to reading the text, that character will be stuck in our head and transfer
into our reading! This takes me to my next topic.
Detail is very important when it comes to anything, and that
is something films lack. A great example of this is the connection between
Katniss, the brave volunteer in place of her young sister from District 12, and Rue, the young girl from
District 11. In the book, It explains that Katniss felt connection and acted as
her protector because she reminded her of her sister. The book really takes
time to develop their relationship throughout the book. The film quickly suggests
that they are friends, they help each other out for a bit, and then Rue is
killed.
Last of all, the movie always changes the original scene or
adds scenes. Many times, a book has a very difficult scene that cannot be
reenacted to be put in movie so they water it down a lot. This makes the film a
bit less enjoyable. We read such an exciting scene only to see a completely
different scene in its place. An example of this is when Peeta hurt his leg towards
the end, he ended up having it amputated. In the movie he was perfectly fine
after some ointment.
All in all, the way a text differs into a film is pretty dreadful.
Nobody likes the watered down version of something. We expect the same excitement
and suspense that we got when we were reading the book! There are plenty more
ways that a move differs from a book,
but these are the top three reasons. Although many people continue to enjoy the
book just as much as the movie, the film version still gives us a good time
when watched.